2024 - (1 First Team | 2 Second Team | 3 Total)
Alec Burnett - First Team (RP)
Ryan Bilka - Second Team (SP)
Diego Tavarez - Second Team (DH)

---

2023 - (2 First Team | 2 Second Team | 4 Total)
David Melfi - First Team (C)
Chris Conniff  - First Team (2B)
Connor Hayden - Second Team (SP)
DiMaggio Cazares - Second Team (OF)

---

Jared Gillen - First Team (OF)

2019 - (3 Second Team | 3 Total)
Will Johnson - Second Team (3B)
Joe Silvestrone - Second Team (OF)
Freddy Sabido - Second Team (DH)

2018 - (4 First Team | 2 Second Team | 6 Total)
Northeast Conference (NEC) Coach of the Year: Jim Carone
Sean Mazzio - First Team (SS)
Freddy Sabido - First Team (DH)
Neil Abbatiello - First Team (SP)
Nick Robino - First Team (RP)
Phil Capra - Second Team (C)
Kyle Cala- Second Team (OF)

2017 - (3 First Team | 2 Second Team | 5 Total)
Anthony Godino - First Team (OF)
Austin Goeke - First Team (SP)
Danny Marsh - First Team (SP)
Phil Capra - Second Team (C)
Freddy Sabido - Second Team (DH)

2016 - (1 First Team | 4 Second Team | 5 Total)
Ben Ruta - First Team (OF)
Phil Capra - Second Team (DH)
Austin Goeke - Second Team (SP)
Nathan Hunt - Second Team (RP)
Nick Mascelli - Second Team (SS)

2015 - (5 First Team | 5 Total)
Northeast Conference (NEC) Coach of the Year: Jim Carone
Northeast Conference (NEC) Player of the Year: Nick Dini
Steven Bloodworth - First Team (RP)
Nick Dini - First Team (C)
Anthony Godino (DH)
Nolan Long (SP)
Ben Ruta (OF)

2014 - (1 Second Team / 1 Total)
Chris Smith - Second Team (OF)

2013 - (2 First Team | 1 Second Team | 3 Total)
Ian Miller - First Team (OF)
Nick Dini - First Team (C)
Chris Smith - Second Team (DH)

2012 - (2 Second Team | 2 Total)
Ian Miller - Second Team (OF)
Ryan Van Spronsen - Second Team (SP)

2011 - (1 Second Team | 1 Total)
Jon Lucas - Second Team (DH)

2010 - (2 First Team | 3 Second Team | 5 Total)
Jon Lucas - First Team (DH)
Brian Martutartus - First Team (SS)
Vin Avella - Second Team (1B)
Seth Boyd - Second Team (2B)
David Rees - Second Team (RP)

2009 - (2 First Team | 1 Second Team | 3 Total)
Northeast Conference (NEC) Coach of the Year: Joe Litterio
Northeast Conference (NEC) Pitcher of the Year: Matt Watson
Matt Watson - First Team (SP)
Damian Csakai - First Team (OF)
Seth Boyd - Second Team (2B)

2008 - (1 First Team / 3 Second Team / 4 Total)
Northeast Conference (NEC) Pitcher of the Year: Joe Testa
Joe Testa - First Team (SP)
Vin Avella - Second Team (1B)
Damian Csakai - Second Team (OF)
Chris Drechsel - Second Team (C)

2007 - (1 First Team | 2 Second Team | 3 Total)
Joey DiGeronimo - First Team (SS)
Pete Delleani - Second Team (2B)
Chris Drechsel - Second Team (C)

2006 - (2 Second Team | 2 Total)
Chris Drechsel - Second Team (Utility)
Nick Papa - Second Team (OF)

2005 - (2 First Team | 2 Second Team | 4 Total)
Joe Malfettano - First Team (2B)
Troy Sogluizzo - First Team (DH)
Matt Mastrianni - Second Team (OF)
Nick Papa - Second Team (OF)

2004 - (1 Second Team | 1 Total)
Nick Papa - Second Team (OF)

2003 - (2 Second Team | 2 Total)
Chris Dick - Second Team (1B)
Troy Sogluizzo - Second Team (DH)

2002 - (1 Second Team | 1 Total)
Chris Dick - Second Team (1B)

2001 - (1 First Team | 1 Total)
Joe LaRocca - First Team (DH)

2000 - (2 First Team | 1 Second Team | 3 Total)
Northeast Conference (NEC) Tournament MVP: Steve Coppola
Gil Barkman - First Team (DH)
Mike Cerminaro - First Team (SS)
John Spinelli - Second Team (OF)

1999 - (2 First Team | 1 Second Team | 3 Total)
Joe Francisco - First Team (OF)
John Spinelli - First Team (DH)
Gil Barkman - Second Team (3B)

1998 - 1
Joe Francisco (OF)

1997 - 1
Northeast Conference (NEC) Pitcher of the Year: Mark Nugent
Mark Nugent - First Team (SP)

1994 - 2
Keith Bolognese (OF)
Randy Chirumbolo (SP)

1993 - 3
Chris DeDomenico (1B)
George Gagliardi (SP)
Jack Scholz (OF)

1992 - 3
Northeast Conference (NEC) Coach of the Year: Rich Vitaliano
George Gagliardi (SP)
Brent Harvie (OF)
Jack Sholz (2B)

1991 - 2
Dean Esposito (1B)
John White (OF)

1989 - 2
Northeast Conference (NEC) Rookie of the Year: John White (First-Ever NEC Rookie of the Year Award Winner)
Len Cancelleri (DH)
Mike Venezia (OF)

1988 - 2
Len Cancelleri (DH)
Mike Venezia (OF)